Hallucinations In Legal Practice: A Comparative Case Law Analysis

TitleHallucinations In Legal Practice: A Comparative Case Law Analysis
AuthorDr. Bakht Munir, Dr. Muhammad Zubair Abbasi, W. Blake Wilson & Allen Colombo Jr.
AffiliationDr. Bakht Munir, University of Kansas School of Law; Dr. Muhammad Zubair Abbasi, School of Law and Social Sciences, Royal Holloway, University of London; W. Blake Wilson, The University of Kansas School of Law; Allen Colombo Jr., The University of Kansas School of Law
Region/CountryDr. Bakht Munir, US; Dr. Muhammad Zubair Abbasi, UK; W. Blake Wilson, US; Allen Colombo Jr., US
IssueVol. 2025 No. 2 (Spring 2025)
Pages85-109
DownloadPDF
DOI10.55574/qkmd5023
Permalinkhttps://ijlet.org/5-2-3/
KeywordsCases of Hallucination; Standing Orders on Hallucinations; Generative AI; AI and Malpractices; AI and Civil Liabilities
AbstractThe employment of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in legal operations raised concerns about ethical challenges and their potential consequences. Among other issues, hallucinations refer to a phenomenon whereby AI systems generate plausible but inaccurate or fabricated responses. In legal matters, where precision and compliance with authorities are paramount, inconsistency with legal doctrines and judicial precedents may lead to wrong legal advice or decisions. AI tools such as ChatGPT and Lexis +AI exhibit human-like intelligence. Still, their fabricated responses could lead to real-world consequences such as professional misconduct resulting in civil liabilities. This article contributes to the following aspects: it compares judicial scholarship evolved on AI hallucinations in the USA, Pakistan, UK, Australia, and Canada. It examines the standing orders and policy guidelines set by the bar and bench constituting patchwork with competing outcomes. The article emphasizes uniform and comprehensive policy guidelines for the responsible use of generative AI tools in legal operations.