Deciphering the Hero Villain Narrative: A Functionalist Comparison of AI Governance in the U.S. and China

TitleDeciphering the Hero Villain Narrative: A Functionalist Comparison of AI Governance in the U.S. and China
AuthorHaocheng Zhan, Ruiyi Chen, Xi Liu & Donghui Liu
AffiliationHaocheng Zhan, Civil, Commercial, and Economic Law School, China University of Political Science and Law (CUPL); Ruiyi Chen, International Law School, CUPL; Xi Liu, Law School, CUPL; Donghui Liu, Commercial, and Economic Law School, CUPL
Region/CountryChina
IssueVol. 2025 No. 2 (Spring 2025)
Pages20-84
DownloadPDF
Permalinkhttps://ijlet.org/5-2-2/
KeywordsAI; Comparative Law; U.S.; China; Functionalist
AbstractThe previous comparative studies on artificial intelligence (AI) governance between the U.S. and China have primarily focused on the differences between the two countries and their ideological antagonism. This paper aims to delve deeper into this issue by addressing the following questions: (1) what are the key differences in AI governance between the U.S. and China? (2) Are these differences rooted in fundamental distinctions such as ideology, or are they pragmatist responses to differing stages of AI development? To answer these questions, this study includes a broader range of policy documents related to AI governance from both countries for a more thorough comparison. The legal instruments compared include 36 federal and 25 state-level documents from the U.S., with a portion referenced in the annex, and 38 from China. Furthermore, this paper employs a functionalist comparative approach to analyse the policy documents included. In this vein, this paper categorizes the aforementioned legal instruments into three groups – facilitation, regulation, and international cooperation – based on the roles played by their rules, and examines the specific measures for AI governance in both countries. The findings demonstrate that the differences in the two countries’ approaches can largely be attributed to their respective stages of technological development—the U.S. is focused on “maintaining leadership,” while China is focused on “catching up.” Despite these differences, both place considerable emphasis on the economic and strategic benefits brought by technological advancements, while relatively underestimating the potential risks.
DOI10.55574/xmvl8555